Should I Speak With the Other Driver’s Insurance Company Directly in Florida?

The aftermath of an accident can be complex, especially when it comes to dealing with insurance companies. As a Personal Injury Lawyer at The Dash Cam Lawyer®, I often receive questions from potential clients about whether they should engage directly with the other driver’s insurance company in Florida. In this blog post, we’ll explore this topic, shedding light on the dynamics of insurance conversations and offering guidance on how to approach them wisely.

The Modified Comparative Negligence System in Florida

Florida’s legal landscape for personal injury claims operates under a new (As of March 24, 2023) modified comparative negligence system. This means that when an accident occurs, the degree of fault is evaluated, and compensation may be adjusted accordingly, UNLESS someone is deemed to be over 50% at fault and in that case, they are entitled to zero recovery.

  1. Definition of Modified Negligence: Modified negligence is a legal principle that apportions fault among parties involved in an accident. In Florida, this system considers the percentage of fault assigned to each party, impacting the final compensation awarded.  However, if someone is deemed more than 50% at fault they lose their right to recover anything at all.
  2. Impact on Compensation: One crucial aspect of this system is that compensation is not automatically barred if you share some degree of fault for the accident. However, the compensation you receive may be reduced in proportion to your assigned percentage of fault, unless you are over 50% at fault.
  3. Proportional Reduction: For instance, if you are found to be 20% at fault, your compensation would be reduced by that percentage. So, if the total compensation determined is $10,000, you would receive $8,000 after the reduction.  However, if you are found 50.5% at fault, your right to recover anything at all is completely barred. 
  4. Importance of Understanding the System: Understanding the nuances of Florida’s modified comparative negligence system is paramount. It empowers individuals involved in accidents to make informed decisions about how to proceed, especially when engaging with insurance companies.

Why Understanding the Nuances Is Crucial

  1. Informed Decision-Making: Armed with knowledge about the modified comparative negligence system, individuals can make informed decisions about whether to pursue a claim, negotiate with an insurance company, or seek legal representation.
  2. Protecting Your Rights: Knowing the intricacies of the system helps individuals protect their rights effectively. It allows them to navigate conversations with insurance adjusters and other involved parties with a clear understanding of how fault allocation may impact their compensation.
  3. Seeking Legal Counsel: Given the complexity of this legal framework, seeking legal counsel becomes crucial. A personal injury lawyer, well-versed in Florida’s laws, can provide tailored advice, assess the strength of your case, and guide you through the process.
  4. Building a Strong Case: Understanding the system aids in building a strong case. Whether gathering evidence for negotiations or potential litigation, being cognizant of the comparative negligence principles ensures a strategic approach to presenting your side of the story.

Practical Advice 

What are the pros and cons of speaking directly with the other driver’s insurance company? While it may be tempting to communicate directly with the other driver’s insurance company (and some people feel they are required to contact the other insurance company but are not), it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons. On the one hand, it allows you to present your side of the story of what happened; on the other hand however, it could inadvertently harm your case, as you may be locked into a recorded statement where you say too much or circumstances change down the road. It’s advisable to consult with a personal injury lawyer before engaging in direct conversations. Our team at The Dash Cam Lawyer®, can provide tailored advice based on your specific situation.

Building a Strong Case

If you decide to pursue direct communication with the other driver’s insurance company, arm yourself with strong evidence. Document the accident scene, gather witness statements, and obtain a copy of the police report. As a huge proponent of dash cameras in cars, you need to have one of these!!! This meticulous approach can significantly strengthen your case and improve your chances of receiving the compensation you deserve.

Contact Our Florida Car Accident Attorney

Getting insurance talks after an accident in Florida requires a strategic and informed approach. Understanding the state’s modified comparative negligence system and seeking professional guidance are essential steps to ensure your rights are protected. If you find yourself grappling with the aftermath of an accident and have questions about engaging with insurance companies, don’t hesitate to reach out to The Dash Cam Lawyer®. Contact us today at 561-DASHCAM or online for a free consultation with an experienced personal injury lawyer.

Start Your Free
Consultation Today

Call us or complete the form below.
We'll keep your information confidential.

    Lake Worth Office

    101 North J Street,
    Suite 2 Lake Worth, FL 33460

    Belle Glade Office

    1100 South Main Street,
    Belle Glade, FL 33430

    By appointment only

    Download Our Personal Injury App Today

    Our app serves as a checklist for any type of injury and is especially beneficial at the scene of the accident - like having a personal injury attorney there with you!