The Other Driver Has a Dash Cam: What It Means for Your Florida Claim

Free consultation · Call 561-561-DASH (3274)Consulta gratuita · Llame al 561-561-DASH (3274)

Written and reviewed by Shannon J. Sagan, Fla. Bar #10793. Updated: November 16, 2026.

Two cars after a crash at a Florida intersection, each with a dash camera on the windshield
Illustration, not an actual crash.

Short answer: The other driver’s dash cam may hold the clearest record of your crash. It can help you or hurt you. The driver usually does not have to hand it over just because you ask, and most cameras record over old files on a loop. Note that the camera exists, tell the officer, do not discuss fault with any insurer until a lawyer has reviewed your case, and get a preservation letter out quickly.

I am Shannon J. Sagan, The Dash Cam Lawyer®. I have been a lawyer for more than 21 years, and my practice focuses on injury claims across Palm Beach County, from my Palm Springs office and, by appointment, my Belle Glade office.

Before anything else: the insurer rule

Do not call your own insurance company before you speak with an attorney. Your policy has a duty to cooperate, but that duty does not require you to do it immediately or to answer questions before you have advice. Never give a recorded statement to any insurer first, including your own.

The adjuster may already know what the clip shows; you do not. A small gap between your memory and the video can be used to question everything else you say.

If the other driver’s insurer says the video settles fault and asks for a recorded statement:

  1. Ask for a copy of the video in writing. The request creates a record, even if they decline.
  2. Do not describe the crash or accept a fault percentage on that call.
  3. Write down the adjuster’s name and the claim number so preservation demands reach the right place.

What their camera may show, and why it cuts both ways

The footage may show the signal color before impact, both drivers’ speed and lane changes, your brake lights and turn signal, and road conditions. Audio is a separate issue. Florida generally requires all participants’ prior consent to record a conversation where there is a reasonable expectation of privacy. If the clip captures such a conversation, have counsel assess whether the audio was lawfully recorded before using or sharing it.

Sometimes the footage proves you were hit. Sometimes it shows a rolling stop or a late signal that the insurer will say contributed to the crash. Under Florida’s modified comparative fault rule, § 768.81(6), Fla. Stat., a person found more than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm recovers nothing. At 50 percent or less, the recovery is reduced by that share. A few seconds of video can move that percentage, so watch it with a lawyer before you commit to a version of events.

Can I make the other driver give me the footage?

Usually not on your own, at least not right away. Before a lawsuit is filed, a private driver generally has no obligation to send you a copy, and many send it only to their own insurer.

What you can do is help keep it from being lost. A preservation letter from a lawyer puts the driver and the driver’s insurer on written notice that the video is evidence in a claim. If evidence disappears after that kind of notice, a Florida court may impose consequences, which can include telling the jury it may infer the missing evidence was unfavorable. Once a lawsuit is filed, the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure provide formal tools to request recordings and devices and to subpoena records from people who are not parties.

The catch is time. A clip nobody saved may be gone within hours or days.

What to do if you notice their camera

At the scene, if you are safe and able:

  • Photograph the camera, the plate, and the vehicle, and get the driver’s contact and insurance information.
  • Tell the responding officer about the dash cam and ask that it be noted. Per FLHSMV, crash reports can take up to 10 days to become available.
  • Ask the driver, politely, to save the video.
  • Save your own footage if you have a camera. My guide on how to use dashcam footage in a Florida car accident claim walks through the steps.

In the first days after the crash, get medical care: for PIP medical benefits, § 627.736(1)(a), Fla. Stat., requires initial services and care within 14 days. Do not post about the crash. If the other driver posts the clip, save the link and send it to your lawyer.

When the other vehicle is a truck, van, or rideshare car

A commercial or rideshare camera usually belongs to a company, so the preservation letter may need to reach the carrier, its insurer, and the camera vendor. For semis, see truck dash cam footage in a Florida truck accident claim. For box trucks and vans, see my pages on delivery truck and box truck crashes in Palm Springs and commercial vehicle accident claims in Palm Beach County.

Deadlines that keep running

Waiting for the footage does not stop any clock. For most negligence claims that arose after March 24, 2023, § 95.11(5)(a), Fla. Stat., sets a two-year deadline; claims against government agencies follow different rules. If the at-fault driver carries little coverage, your own uninsured motorist coverage can matter. The Florida Bar’s automobile insurance consumer pamphlet explains the coverage types.

How I use the other driver’s footage

I do not promise results; facts, coverage, injuries, and proof decide every case. My early work usually includes preservation letters, a request for the original file, and a fault analysis before you give any statement. If you have your own clip too, see whether you still need a lawyer when you have dash cam footage. Local pages: Palm Springs car accident lawyer and car accident lawyer in Belle Glade, FL.

No dash cam of your own? My Community Dash Cam Safety Program has given away more than 1,400 free dash cams to Palm Beach County drivers. Requesting one does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Frequently asked questions

What should I do if the other driver has a dash cam?

Photograph the camera and the vehicle, get the driver’s contact and insurance information, and tell the officer the camera exists. Then talk to a lawyer quickly so a preservation letter can go out before the camera records over the file.

Can the other driver’s dash cam footage be used against me?

Yes. Video can show your speed, signal use, or lane position. Under § 768.81(6), Fla. Stat., a finding that you were over 50 percent at fault bars recovery, and a share of 50 percent or less reduces it.

Does the other driver have to give me their dash cam video?

Usually not just because you ask before a lawsuit. A preservation letter puts them on notice not to destroy it. If a lawsuit is filed, the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure provide formal ways to request it.

The other driver’s insurer says their video proves I was at fault. Should I give a statement?

No. Do not give a recorded statement to any insurer first, and do not accept a fault percentage over the phone. Ask for a copy of the video in writing and talk to a lawyer before you describe the crash.

Should I call my own insurance company first?

Not before you speak with an attorney. The duty to cooperate in your policy does not require you to do it immediately, and you should never give a recorded statement to any insurer first.

Talk with me about the other driver’s video

If the other driver had a dash cam, or a truck or fleet vehicle with cameras hit you, call 561-561-DASH (3274) for a free consultation. Se habla español. No fee unless I recover for you. No recovery, no fees or costs.

The Dash Cam Lawyer®
Shannon J. Sagan, Fla. Bar #10793
Palm Springs office: 3003 S. Congress Ave, Suite 2E, Palm Springs, FL 33461
Belle Glade office: 1100 South Main Street, Belle Glade, FL 33430 (by appointment)
Phone: 561-561-DASH (3274)

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Interior view of a vehicle's dashcam recording the road ahead.

Looking for an accident Lawyer near you in Palm Beach County?

Find Out What Your Case Is Worth - Free Consultation
¿Busca un abogado de accidentes cerca de usted en el condado de Palm Beach?

Averigüe cuánto vale su caso. Consulta gratis.

Call me or complete the form below.
I will keep your information confidential.

Llámeme al 561-561-DASH (3274) o complete el formulario a continuación.
Mantendré su información confidencial.

    How did you hear about us?

    Palm Springs Office

    3003 S. Congress Ave,
    Suite 2E, Palm Springs, FL 33461

    Belle Glade Office

    1100 South Main Street,
    Belle Glade, FL 33430

    By appointment only