4 Florida Car Insurance Companies I Would Absolutely Avoid, and Why Their Drivers So Often Have No Injury Coverage

By Shannon J. Sagan, The Dash Cam Lawyer®, Fla. Bar #10793

Quick answer: Florida requires drivers to carry only $10,000 in personal injury protection (PIP) and $10,000 in property damage liability. It does not require bodily injury (BI) liability coverage, the coverage that pays when a driver injures you. In my opinion, that law is the root problem. Below are the 4 auto insurers I personally would not buy from, based on my professional experience handling numerous claims with them. For each one I also show the state complaint data, and I explain how to protect your family no matter who insures the other driver.

Florida car insurance declarations page with blank bodily injury and uninsured motorist lines and a red Coverage Denied stamp
Illustration.

Twice in one week

Twice in one week, drivers insured by a nonstandard carrier have hit and injured two of my clients, and neither driver has bodily injury coverage.

That means there is no liability policy to pay for my clients’ injuries. Both drivers were street legal in Florida. They had the minimum policy the state requires, and the minimum does not include a single dollar for the people they hurt.

I have practiced law for more than 21 years and have been in the personal injury field for more than 25. In my opinion, the situation has never been worse. And despite many of my clients telling me they have full coverage, 8 out of 10 do not have uninsured motorist (UM) coverage, the one coverage that would have paid them.

So I am going to say what I think, plainly, and back up every fact with a public source.

What Florida law actually requires

  • PIP: $10,000. Think of it as health insurance. It pays 80% of reasonable medical expenses and 60% of lost income, no matter who caused the crash. You must get initial care within 14 days. If a qualifying provider does not find an emergency medical condition, medical benefits are capped at $2,500. (Fla. Stat. 627.736)
  • Property damage liability: $10,000 per crash. (Fla. Stat. 324.022)
  • Bodily injury liability: not required to register an ordinary car. The state’s registration requirement is PIP and property damage only. (FLHSMV insurance requirements)

BI becomes required only after something has already gone wrong:

  • After a crash that triggers Florida’s financial responsibility law. The state can suspend the license and registration of an uninsured driver, and proof of coverage at $10,000/$20,000 BI can be required going forward. (Fla. Stat. 324.051, 324.021(7))
  • After an unpaid crash judgment. The suspension stays until the judgment is handled, and the driver must keep proof of coverage for 3 years. (Fla. Stat. 324.131)
  • After a DUI conviction or plea. The driver must carry $100,000/$300,000 BI and $50,000 property damage for 3 years. (Fla. Stat. 324.023)

In other words, Florida generally waits until someone gets hurt before it asks for injury coverage. In my opinion, that is backwards.

Florida is the ONLY state that requires car insurance but does not require bodily injury coverage. How moronic and illogical is that? Although we Floridians enjoy lots of great things and freedoms here in Florida, the freedom of someone rear-ending and injuring another person or family, and for the most part not having to be accountable, is not one of them.

Lawmakers have not fixed it

Bills have been on the table in the past to try to get Florida up to speed with the rest of the country, but as always, politicians (both sides) do not seem to care or listen.

I explained in August that Florida did not repeal no-fault in 2026. Nothing has changed since then. In my opinion, Florida should require bodily injury coverage. If you agree, tell your state representative and senator.

The 4 Florida car insurance companies I would absolutely avoid

How to read the numbers. Each year, the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR) publishes a complaint index for each insurer under state law. The index compares an insurer’s share of confirmed consumer complaints with its share of premiums in that line of insurance. 1.00 is average. 4.00 means four times the average share of complaints for its size.

The counts are small, so the index can swing from year to year. That is why I show two years for each company. A complaint index does not prove wrongdoing in any single claim. In my opinion, though, a company that keeps landing several times above average is telling you something.

The numbers below come from the complaint index tables (private passenger auto) in the OIR 2023 Annual Report (2022 data) and the OIR 2024 Annual Report (2023 data). Both reports are listed on OIR’s Annual Reports page. For comparison, in the same tables State Farm Mutual scored 0.83 for 2022 and 0.65 for 2023.

The OIR numbers at a glance

Florida OIR private passenger auto complaint index (confirmed complaints in parentheses). 1.00 is average.
Insurer2022 index2023 indexOIR exam finding in this post
United Automobile Insurance Company8.31 (25)4.01 (7)Financial exam, report dated Feb. 19, 2025: reserves deficient by about $90.9 million as of Dec. 31, 2023; about $112.6 million of adverse development later recognized
Direct General Insurance Company5.77 (41, the most in the 2022 table)2.56 (12)None cited in this post
Infinity Auto Insurance Company2.43 (10)4.66 (8)None cited in this post
Infinity Indemnity Insurance Company1.89 (4)6.65 (6)None cited in this post
Ocean Harbor Casualty Insurance Company5.07 (15)2.00 (4)Market conduct exam, report dated May 14, 2024: PIP not paid within 30 days in 11 of 109 sampled paid PIP claims (10.1%); non-drivable vehicles not inspected within 5 days in 42 of 109 sampled total-loss claims (38.5%)
State Farm Mutual (for comparison)0.830.65Benchmark only

Sources: OIR 2023 Annual Report (2022 data) and OIR 2024 Annual Report (2023 data), plus the two OIR exam reports linked in each company section below. The table repeats the public record only. My opinions are in each company section.

1. United Automobile Insurance Company (United Auto)

The public record:

  • OIR private passenger auto complaint index for 2022: 8.31, based on 25 confirmed complaints. (OIR 2023 Annual Report)
  • OIR index for 2023: 4.01, based on 7 confirmed complaints. (OIR 2024 Annual Report)
  • OIR financial examination, report dated February 19, 2025: OIR examiners found the company’s loss and loss adjustment expense reserves as of December 31, 2023 were deficient by about $90.9 million net of reinsurance. The report notes the company later recognized about $112.6 million of adverse development in its 2024 annual statement. (OIR listing for this examination report)

My opinion: I would not buy a policy from United Auto. A complaint index of roughly 4 to 8 times average, plus a state finding that its claim reserves fell short, is enough for me to shop elsewhere.

My experience: Additionally, in my professional career, United Automobile takes the cake when it comes to denying and delaying claims, more than any other company I have dealt with, and I’m talking about many claims that actually involve their own insured. In my experience, their customer service is poor and slow. In my opinion, United should be the last company you want to have as your insurer.

2. Direct General Insurance Company (Direct General)

The public record:

  • OIR private passenger auto complaint index for 2022: 5.77. Its 41 confirmed complaints were the most of any private passenger auto insurer in OIR’s table that year. (OIR 2023 Annual Report)
  • OIR index for 2023: 2.56, based on 12 confirmed complaints. (OIR 2024 Annual Report)

My opinion: Direct General improved in 2023, but it was still more than two and a half times average. I would not buy from Direct General.

My experience: As for Direct General, I’m starting to see more of them in my clients’ cases over the past 2 to 3 years. In my practice, the majority of Direct General policies I’ve seen have $0 bodily injury coverage, and in my experience, their customer service is poor and slow when I’ve dealt with them.

3. Infinity (a Kemper company)

OIR lists two Infinity companies separately:

  • Infinity Auto Insurance Company: OIR index 2.43 for 2022 (10 confirmed complaints) and 4.66 for 2023 (8). (OIR 2023 and 2024 Annual Reports)
  • Infinity Indemnity Insurance Company: OIR index 1.89 for 2022 (4) and 6.65 for 2023 (6). (same reports)

My opinion: Both Infinity companies moved in the wrong direction from 2022 to 2023. I would not buy from Infinity.

My experience: Infinity is also a crapshoot, but most of the time I’m seeing their insureds driving around with bare-bones coverage and no bodily injury coverage to pay if their driver hurts someone.

4. Ocean Harbor Casualty Insurance Company (Ocean Harbor)

The public record:

  • OIR private passenger auto complaint index for 2022: 5.07 (15 confirmed complaints) and 2023: 2.00 (4). (OIR 2023 and 2024 Annual Reports)
  • OIR targeted market conduct examination, final report dated May 14, 2024, covering private passenger auto claims from 2019 through 2021 (OIR listing for this examination report):
    • In 11 of 109 sampled PIP claims closed with payment (10.1%), examiners found PIP benefits were not paid within 30 days of written notice, as Florida’s PIP statute requires.
    • In 42 of 109 sampled total-loss claims (38.5%), examiners found non-drivable vehicles were not inspected within 5 days, as its own claims manual requires.

My opinion: When the state’s own examiners find late PIP payments in about 1 of every 10 sampled paid claims, that matters to me. PIP is the first money an injured person gets. I would not buy from Ocean Harbor.

My experience: I have not seen a BI policy with Ocean Harbor in almost 10 years now.

The “cheapest legal policy” sales pitch

I am not naming any agency here. This section is my opinion about a practice.

In my opinion, too many Florida drivers walk into a storefront or click through a website, ask for “the cheapest legal policy,” and walk out with exactly that: PIP and property damage, no bodily injury, and therefore no UM. Under Fla. Stat. 627.727, UM is tied to policies that include bodily injury coverage. No BI means no UM.

Right now the economy is bad and Florida’s insurance rates are extremely high, so I get why people want to save. But I have seen every one of these insurance companies, at one time or another, not provide coverage to their own insured for some reason or another, and if you don’t have a lawyer to fight them, in my experience, they often get away with it. Just because you are paying an insurance company every month does not mean it will provide coverage for you when it comes time to ask for help. Especially these 4 companies.

I believe anyone who sells auto insurance in Florida should explain that trade-off in plain words before taking the premium. A low monthly payment is not protection.

Questions to ask any agent:

  1. What would it cost to add bodily injury coverage at $25,000/$50,000? At $100,000/$300,000?
  2. What would UM cost at the same limits?
  3. Is there a signed UM rejection form on my file? Can I have a copy?
  4. Does “full coverage” on my quote include UM? Show me the line.

PIP vs. UM, and why “full coverage” isn’t

PIP and UM are different coverages, and most people I meet confuse them.

  • PIP: think of it as health insurance. It is the no-fault coverage you are required to carry, and it pays 80% of reasonable medical bills up to $10,000 ($2,500 without an emergency medical condition finding), plus 60% of lost income, within the same limit. You must start treatment within 14 days. It pays nothing for pain and suffering. (Fla. Stat. 627.736)
  • UM steps in when the at-fault driver has no bodily injury coverage, too little of it, or drives away. It can pay for medical bills beyond PIP, lost wages, and, when your injury meets Florida’s threshold, pain and suffering. It is optional. A named insured can reject it in writing, and that rejection can carry over at renewal. (Fla. Stat. 627.727)
  • “Full coverage” is not a legal term in Florida. It is sales language. Many policies people call “full coverage” have collision, comprehensive, PIP, and BI, and still no UM. If you are reading this now and you are one of the many saying you have full coverage, I urge you to immediately check your policy and see if you have UM coverage. I wrote about this in detail in Most of My Clients Are Convinced They Have Full Coverage.

A $10,000 PIP limit can run out quickly after a serious crash. In my opinion, UM is the most important coverage on your auto policy, because it protects you from every driver on this list and every driver who carries nothing at all.

Your 60-second policy check

In my experience, if you have one of these 4 carriers, it is extremely likely there is no bodily injury coverage on your policy. Open your insurer’s app or your latest renewal and find the declarations page:

  1. Bodily injury liability: is there a dollar amount, or does it say none?
  2. Uninsured/underinsured motorist: is it listed, or rejected?
  3. Every car and every driver: check the second car and the teen driver too.

For the full checklist, see my post Florida’s Cheapest Legal Car Policy Could Leave Your Family Paying the Bills.

If you are already hurt, before you call any insurer

  • Do not call your own insurance company before you speak with an attorney.
  • Your policy’s duty to cooperate does not require you to do it immediately. You can talk with a lawyer first.
  • Never give a recorded statement to any insurer, yours or the other driver’s, before you speak with an attorney.

If the driver who hit you had little or no coverage, read Hit by an Uninsured Driver in Florida? Your Legal Options in Palm Beach County.

Frequently asked questions

Is bodily injury liability coverage required in Florida?

Not to register an ordinary private car. Florida requires $10,000 PIP and $10,000 property damage liability (Fla. Stat. 627.736, 324.022). BI can become required after certain crashes, unpaid judgments, or a DUI (Fla. Stat. 324.051, 324.131, 324.023).

Which Florida car insurance companies would you avoid?

In my opinion: United Automobile Insurance Company, Direct General Insurance Company, Infinity (Infinity Auto and Infinity Indemnity), and Ocean Harbor Casualty Insurance Company. Each had a Florida OIR private passenger auto complaint index above the 1.00 average in both 2022 and 2023. The numbers are facts from the state. Whether to avoid them is my opinion, based on that data and my experience handling claims with them.

How can I check an insurance company’s complaint record in Florida?

Look at the complaint index tables in the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation’s annual report, and check the company’s record with the Florida Department of Financial Services before you buy.

If I only have PIP and property damage, can I buy UM?

Under Fla. Stat. 627.727, UM is tied to policies that include bodily injury liability. A PIP-and-property-damage-only policy does not carry UM, so ask your agent to quote both together.

Does “full coverage” include uninsured motorist coverage?

Not necessarily. “Full coverage” is not a legal term in Florida, and UM can be rejected in writing (Fla. Stat. 627.727). The only way to know is to read your declarations page.

What does Florida PIP actually pay?

Think of it as health insurance. It pays 80% of reasonable medical expenses and 60% of lost income, up to $10,000 combined, if you get initial care within 14 days. Without an emergency medical condition finding, medical benefits stop at $2,500. PIP does not pay for pain and suffering (Fla. Stat. 627.736).

Has Florida passed a law requiring bodily injury coverage?

No. Bills have been proposed in the past, but none has passed. Florida still does not require BI to register an ordinary car.

Talk to The Dash Cam Lawyer®

If a driver with little or no insurance hurt you or someone in your family in Palm Springs, Belle Glade, or anywhere in Palm Beach County, call me at 561-561-DASH (3274) for a free consultation. I have more than 21 years as a lawyer, and I will review your policy and the other driver’s coverage with you.

No fee unless I recover for you.

No recovery, no fees or costs.

This article is from The Dash Cam Lawyer® and reflects my opinions, my own professional experience, and general information, not legal advice. Complaint data comes from the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, and every company may improve or change. Check current information before you buy. Shannon J. Sagan, Palm Springs and Belle Glade, Florida.

Sources

  1. Fla. Stat. 627.736 (PIP). https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0600-0699/0627/Sections/0627.736.html
  2. Fla. Stat. 324.022 (property damage liability). https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0300-0399/0324/Sections/0324.022.html
  3. Fla. Stat. 324.021, 324.051, 324.131, 324.023 (financial responsibility). https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0300-0399/0324/0324.html
  4. Fla. Stat. 627.727 (UM). https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0600-0699/0627/Sections/0627.727.html
  5. FLHSMV, Florida Insurance Requirements. https://www.flhsmv.gov/insurance/
  6. Florida OIR, 2023 Annual Report (calendar year 2022 complaint indices) and 2024 Annual Report (calendar year 2023 complaint indices), both listed at https://www.floir.gov/resources-and-reports/annual-report
  7. Florida OIR, Examination Report, United Automobile Insurance Company, as of Dec. 31, 2023 (dated Feb. 19, 2025). https://www.floir.gov/property-casualty/property-casualty-financial-oversight/docs-sf/property-casualty-libraries/financial-examination-reports/2023/united-automobile-insurance-company-%2812-31-2023%29
  8. Florida OIR, Targeted Market Conduct Examination, Ocean Harbor Casualty Insurance Company (May 14, 2024). https://www.floir.gov/property-casualty/property-and-casualty-market-regulation/docs-sf/property-casualty-libraries/market-regulation/2024/ocean-harbor-final-report-5-14-2024
Interior view of a vehicle's dashcam recording the road ahead.

Looking for an accident Lawyer near you in Palm Beach County?

Find Out What Your Case Is Worth - Free Consultation
¿Busca un abogado de accidentes cerca de usted en el condado de Palm Beach?

Averigüe cuánto vale su caso. Consulta gratis.

Call me or complete the form below.
I will keep your information confidential.

Llámeme al 561-561-DASH (3274) o complete el formulario a continuación.
Mantendré su información confidencial.

    How did you hear about us?

    Palm Springs Office

    3003 S. Congress Ave,
    Suite 2E, Palm Springs, FL 33461

    Belle Glade Office

    1100 South Main Street,
    Belle Glade, FL 33430

    By appointment only